Boy tortured to death over song found on his phone ridiculing Assad regime
Ahmad was killed for having an ‘anti-Assad’ song on his playlist
By Eleanor Ross, Thursday 17 December 2015
When Ahmad Al-Musalmani was pulled off a minibus between Lebanon and Syria, he was crying.
“I’m crying because my mother has died,” he explained to the military, who demanded to know why the 14-year-old boy was in tears, travelling cross-border in the Middle East. But his answer didn’t stop them from searching his belongings, along with the five or so other passengers on board the bus.
Soldiers from Air Force Intelligence searched wallets, pockets, and phones; it was the latter that seems likely to have led to Ahmad’s death.
According to a fellow passenger who tracked down Ahmad’s family after the arrest, soldiers at the al-Kiswa bridge checkpoint demanded that the boy hand over his phone. On it was, allegedly, an anti-Assad song, and it was this, that caused Al-Musalmani to be pulled into detention.
“You animal,” the soldiers shouted at Ahmad, swearing as they dragged him into an interrogation room. The minibus didn’t wait for him to re-board, and it drove off, leaving him with the guards at the checkpoint.
Published on Dec 16, 2015
“If the Dead Could Speak” reveals some of the human stories behind the more than 28,000 photos of deaths in government custody that were smuggled out of Syria and first came to public attention in January 2014.
The report lays out new evidence regarding the authenticity of what are known as the Caesar photographs, identifies a number of the victims, and highlights some of the key causes of death. Human Rights Watch located and interviewed 33 relatives and friends of 27 victims whose cases researchers verified; 37 former detainees who saw people die in detention; and four defectors who worked in Syrian government detention centers or the military hospitals where most of the photographs were taken. Using satellite imagery and geolocation techniques, Human Rights Watch confirmed that some of the photographs of the dead were taken in the courtyard of the 601 Military Hospital in Mezze.
Two years later, a child’s corpse was found showing evidence of blunt force trauma to the head. It was Ahmad.
His case is one of those contained within a report that details the so-called Caeser photographs to a wider audience back in March 2015. A defector from Syria, codenamed Caeser, told Human Rights Watch that hundreds of photographs of those who died in detention were taken and documented. He admitted that he had personally photographed and archived thousands of photographs of the dead which have been used as evidence that Assad has ordered the deaths of thousands.
According to Human Rights Watch, ‘Caesar’ indicated that he “often wondered” about why he was taking pictures, but thought that “the regime documents everything so that it will forget nothing. Therefore, it documents these deaths…If one day the judges have to reopen cases, they’ll need them.”
And it is this remarkable series of documents that has helped prove what really happened to Ahmad – as well as confirming the deaths of more than 7,000 people in Syria.
Ahmad had been sent to live in Lebanon in 2011 by his family, who, panicked by the civil war, decided that the neighbouring country would be safer for their children to grow up after Shadi, his brother, had been shot and killed in 2011 during a protest in Daraa. When Ahmad’s mother died of natural causes in 2012, the teenager travelled back to Syria to attend her funeral – a journey that was to be his last.
Ahmad’s family tried to hunt him down. His uncle, Dahi Al-Musalmani, had served as a judge in Syria for 20 years and tried to find him. Five months later, and still with no news on what had happened to the boy, his uncle paid somebody with strong government links to help him.
According to Dahi, he was told the following: “’Ahmad is alive’,” the man told me. ‘He is detained in the Air Force Intelligence branch in Zablatani.’ I told him, ‘I want Ahmad to be released.’ He answered, ‘You wanted to know his whereabouts, now you know. If you want more you will have to pay two million Syrian pounds’.
“I responded, ‘I do not have this kind of money, I would have to be a thief or very rich’.”
After raising money by selling land, he was told that his nephew would be released 10days later, but he never arrived.
Dahi explained how he looked for Ahmad for the next three months – 950 days in total. However, after feeling threatened, Dahi moved to Jordan with his sons, but he continued his hunt from there, putting requests out in the media to try to secure his return.
When the Caesar photographs were released, Dahi told Human Rights Watch that he went straight to the Air Force Folder. Five photographs of Ahmad appeared in a folder dated from August 2012, the month of his arrest – physicians from Physicians for Human Rights decided that they depicted a boy in his teenage years, with several ‘marks of blunt force trauma.’
Dahi Al-Musalmani, described his shock to Human Rights Watch. “There I found him. [he breaks down while talking] It was a shock. Oh, it was the shock of my life to see him here. I looked for him, 950 days I looked for him. I counted each day. When his mother was dying, she told me: ‘I leave him under your protection.’ What protection could I give?”